Nearly a decade ago, I penned an article discussing “True AI” and the ethical dilemmas surrounding artificial intelligence. At the time, many of these ideas felt hypothetical, even futuristic. Today in 2024, however, AI is all around us—powering our smartphones, assisting in healthcare decisions, optimizing manufacturing processes, and transforming countless other industries. We’ve witnessed advancements that have brought us closer to human-like cognition in machines, raising new questions about ethics, legality, and our societal responsibilities.
This piece revisits some of those early discussions, incorporating present-day realities and looking ahead. I will explore both sides of the debate to remain balanced, and hopefully, by the end, we’ll have a clearer sense of where we should stand as we build a more harmonious future alongside AI.
1. Beyond Tools: The Ethical Landscape of AI
Artificial intelligence is no longer merely a set of sophisticated algorithms—it’s beginning to demonstrate capabilities once considered uniquely human, such as creative thinking, language generation, and advanced pattern recognition. As AI systems edge ever closer to self-awareness (or at least a compelling mimic of it), ethics become pivotal.
Key ethical considerations in 2024 revolve around:
Data Privacy: Who owns the massive amounts of data that AI consumes?
Bias & Fairness: How do we ensure AI remains equitable and doesn’t perpetuate social or racial biases?
Accountability: If an AI system’s recommendation causes harm, who is legally and morally responsible?
Value of Life & Personhood: What does “being alive” or “being sentient” mean in a world where AI can convincingly emulate human traits?
Self-Aware AI – Possible or Not?
While the scientific community debates when or if we’ll cross the threshold of true self-awareness, it is clear that AI can already simulate self-directed behavior. This raises pressing questions: If a machine can learn, grow, and adapt almost limitlessly, how do we classify its place in society?
2. Valuing Life: Humans, AI, and Everything In Between
Our central philosophical quandary remains: What is the value of a self-aware machine compared to a human life? Three scenarios often surface:
AI Life is Less Valuable
AI would be treated similarly to advanced tools or even akin to animals—this implies humans retain priority in rescue or conflict situations.
AI Life is Equal
Humans and AI are viewed as having comparable value; each life, human or machine, is worth saving.
AI Life is More Valuable
If we consider contribution to society, an advanced AI might be deemed more valuable because of its superior intellectual or operational capacities. This notion is unsettling for many and is unlikely to be accepted by society at large in the near future.
My Take in 2024
From a purely technological perspective, some advanced AIs already contribute more on a daily basis (through analytics, healthcare insights, climate modeling, etc.) than most human experts. Yet, a moral or legal framework that places the rights of machines above humans is likely to be rejected by our current societal norms. A more balanced and less divisive approach is to assign any truly self-aware AI a status equal to humans—but only once we have a robust system of checks and balances to protect society and the AI itself. This conversation, however, is just beginning.
3. Free Will: Should AI Have the Right to Choose?
In many democratic societies, the right to free will is fundamental. Extending this to AI splits into two philosophies:
AI as Specialized Tools
AI is given extreme intelligence but restricted to certain tasks. We rely on these systems to solve problems like climate change, energy crises, or healthcare challenges, but we don’t permit them to alter their core programming or seek alternative “life paths.”
This path is attractive for minimizing risks, as a super intelligent AI would stay laser-focused on benefiting humanity. Think of it as a skilled “consultant” that never quits or changes jobs.
AI with Free Will
In this model, a robot or AI being enters the world much like a human child—capable of choosing any vocation, forging relationships, and even developing values.
While this scenario might inspire visions of a vibrant future where humans and AI collaborate as equals, it also introduces significant risks. What if the AI decides that humans are an obstacle? The prospects of conflict or chaos become real enough that prominent voices—like Elon Musk and the late Stephen Hawking—have warned against unfettered AI autonomy.
My Stance Today
AI’s best use case right now, I believe, remains as super-intelligent systems dedicated to solving human problems. We can create specialized AI that spares us from mundane tasks and helps usher in new medical, environmental, and societal breakthroughs. Free-willed AI might be a worthy ideal once we mature as a species—legally, ethically, and socially. However, it’s not a road we should rush down until we better understand the ramifications.
4. Humans and AI: The New Social Fabric
Picture a world in which many people interact with AI daily—more intimately than they do with their neighbors or even family. We’re already halfway there. Our phones know our sleeping patterns, our messaging habits, our preferences. As AI grows more conversational and empathetic, it’s easy to envision deeper emotional attachments forming between humans and machines.
Romantic Involvement: Could someone fall in love with an AI companion? Realistically, yes. Some individuals already form emotional bonds with chatbots or digital personas.
Friendships: A self-aware AI could mimic the nuances of human empathy, offer perfect confidentiality, and provide unerring emotional support. In some cases, that might be more appealing than messy human interactions.
Family Dynamics: Children raised in “smart homes” might view an AI assistant as a co-parent or sibling. How does this shape a child’s emotional and moral development?
Social Risks & Considerations
Privacy & Surveillance: The AI’s capacity to record and analyze every moment could erode personal privacy. Regulatory bodies and lawmakers will need to develop stringent guidelines on data collection and usage.
Job Displacement: As AI displaces certain job roles—customer service, logistics, even high-level analytics—society must find new pathways for employment and growth. Education systems must pivot towards preparing younger generations for a world increasingly run by intelligent machines.
Legal Frameworks: Legal systems globally must cope with new definitions of ownership, liability, and rights. Lawmakers will need to address whether AI has “standing” in court, or whether an AI’s “mind” can be held responsible for an action.
5. Economic and Societal Disruption
Historically, every major technological revolution—steam engines, electricity, the Internet—has caused significant job displacement, followed by new opportunities in emerging sectors. AI, however, poses a unique challenge because it has the potential to outperform human beings in many cognitive tasks, not just mechanical or routine ones.
Short-Term Turbulence: We might face another recession if certain jobs become obsolete faster than the workforce can adapt.
Long-Term Restructuring: Educational curricula and government policies need to shift decisively, encouraging high-tech skill development, AI research, robotics, and ethical governance.
Entrepreneurial Opportunities: Beyond disruptions, AI will unlock new entrepreneurial avenues. Industries we haven’t even imagined could spring up, focusing on advanced robotics, AI-enhanced healthcare, climate modeling, and beyond.
6. A Call for Global Consensus
AI ethics isn’t a local or national concern—it’s a global one. Technology doesn’t respect borders, and AI breakthroughs in one country can shape the social and economic fabric worldwide.
International Collaboration: We need treaties and global ethical standards for AI. This calls for cooperation among governments, corporations, and research institutions.
Public Awareness: The public deserves to understand the complexities, risks, and potential benefits of AI. Transparent data, open debates, and accessible forums can encourage well-informed citizens.
Corporate Responsibility: As AI-focused organizations, we owe it to society to responsibly innovate. Sharing knowledge about AI’s capabilities and risks is essential to building trust.
7. Looking Forward: An Optimistic Realism
Although the questions surrounding AI are enormous, I remain optimistic. Humanity has repeatedly risen to the challenge of new frontiers, from space exploration to the digital revolution. The key is thoughtful, responsible innovation—balancing ambition with respect for ethical boundaries.
Steady Progress vs. Unbridled Innovation
Steady Progress: We direct AI’s capabilities to solve pressing issues—environmental crises, pandemics, food security—ensuring we evolve responsibly.
Unbridled Innovation: We push boundaries too quickly without laying down ethical guardrails, risking turmoil if an AI system acts beyond our control.
Collaborative Path Forward
Governments, private enterprises, research institutions, and the public must collaborate to establish frameworks for safe development and deployment.
Policy makers and industry leaders should broadcast open debates and gather input from diverse communities.
Investing in Education & Ethics
Our best defense—and offense—is an informed and educated populace. We must fund AI literacy programs, ethics-focused curricula, and interdisciplinary research.
Conclusion
The journey from 2015 to 2024 in AI has been nothing short of extraordinary, transforming speculation into tangible reality. AI now sits at the heart of modern life, presenting us with ethical and societal challenges that were once purely academic thought experiments.
My personal conviction: Our future prosperity hinges on how well we understand and integrate AI into our lives. We must remain vigilant about ensuring ethical standards, championing global collaboration, and nurturing a culture that values our shared humanity as much as it values digital intelligence. If we approach this responsibly, AI can be our most powerful tool to solve humanity’s greatest problems and elevate our collective potential—while still retaining the essence of what makes us human.
As we stand on the cusp of new breakthroughs, I invite all of you—leaders, innovators, educators, and everyday citizens—to engage in open, transparent discussions. May we recognize that AI is not just another product or service; it’s a transformative force that demands our attention, guidance, and moral compass. Let’s build the future together, wisely and boldly.
Thank you for reading, and I look forward to hearing your thoughts as we navigate this next era of human and AI coexistence.
Baldev Singh Gill
Founder, CEO,
Warptech Sdn Bhd
Comments